Read

My Christmas Eve "Confession"

Creator:
Published:
December 4, 2023
December 22, 2017
Exterior marble entryway to St. Patrick's Cathedral in Manhattan at Christmas Mass. The large double doors are open wide and a wreath hangs above the open doors.

Dear Father,

I have a confession. I’m not in the pews on a weekly basis. I’m at Mass on Christmas, Easter, and the occasional Ash Wednesday service.

The last time I went to confession, George W. Bush was in the middle of his first term. So, I guess it’s been approximately…14 years since my last correspondence. My relationship with God has been a work in progress ever since I graduated from high school. I went to Mass weekly in college, yet started to drift away in my mid-twenties.

But, here I am, Father, in my early thirties, insistent that my husband and I attend Christmas Eve Mass while we visit his family in New England. My father-in-law has graciously volunteered to attend with us. From where you are on the altar, we’re the trio in the far-left corner. Everyone else is back at home, preparing for Christmas Eve dinner.

I’m sneaking this Mass in between the shrimp cocktail and the last man standing 10 p.m. reading of T’was the Night Before Christmas. I’m hopeful that you have a welcoming message for me this time, as opposed to the “Haven’t seen these pews this full in awhile!” remarks I’ve heard year after year. I’m looking for a little reassurance that there’s still room for me in this faith.

So, here’s what I need you to know this Christmas:

  • I’m not the most devout, but that doesn’t mean this isn’t important to me. I’m away from my immediate family and childhood customs at Christmas. Besides making thumbprint cookies, 4:30 p.m. Christmas Eve Mass is a tradition I want to incorporate wherever I am. My parents, sister, and I would attend Mass at this time every year before going home for Christmas Eve dinner and a movie. We’d spend Christmas Eve together, just the four of us, before meeting up with extended family on Christmas Day. Even though we haven’t spent the season together these last few years, it’s my small tribute to our routine.
  • Rephrasing the “full pews” remarks to make Mass a little more welcoming would go a long way. With so many people back home with their families, the potential for conflict is rife: everyone jammed into one house, getting stuck with cold water if you landed the last shower spot, little to zero alone time to recharge. A smile with a gentle “Great to see so many smiling faces!” would go much further.
  • I want to feel connected to God again. I admire people who are filled with faith, despite my skeptical nature. Christmas isn’t Christmas to me without thanking God for all the blessings He’s given me throughout the past year. I’m so fortunate, and I want to say thanks before the eggnog starts flowing.

In short, Father, I need you to think of me like you’d think of the Magi this Christmas. I’m coming from elsewhere, still seeking the promise of a better relationship with God. I didn’t bring any incense (just craft beers for the cousins and toys for my nephew), but I’m hoping to share in something special this Christmas Eve. Thanks for opening up a small place in your pews for me.

Sincerely,

Displaced Midwesterner in New England

P.S. Maybe reconsider playing "Go Tell It On The Mountain" during Communion. "Silent Night" is the jam we all want and need.

Creators:
Liz Colleran
Published:
December 4, 2023
December 22, 2017
On a related note...
I Was Hiding My Pain, Not Healing

I Was Hiding My Pain, Not Healing

Alessandra Harris

My Struggle with Porn

My Struggle with Porn

Christine Chu

Saints for the Ordinary Times of a Marriage

Saints for the Ordinary Times of a Marriage

Molly Cruitt

I ‘Believe’ in the Power of Ted Lasso’s Biscuits

I ‘Believe’ in the Power of Ted Lasso’s Biscuits

Carolyn Pirtle

God Sees the Color of My Skin

God Sees the Color of My Skin

Grotto Shares

This Kid Raised $1M for Drought-Affected Farmers

This Kid Raised $1M for Drought-Affected Farmers

Grotto Shares

Should We Believe Kanye's Conversion Is Authentic?

Should We Believe Kanye's Conversion Is Authentic?

Emily Mae Mentock

Quick Guide to Fasting and Abstinence During Lent

Quick Guide to Fasting and Abstinence During Lent

Lisa Greey Lytwyn

"In the Waters of Lourdes"

"In the Waters of Lourdes"

Josie Kuhlman

How Resting on Sundays Can Transform Your Perspective

How Resting on Sundays Can Transform Your Perspective

Christian Santa Maria

3 Ways to Practice Everyday Mindfulness

3 Ways to Practice Everyday Mindfulness

Krista Steele

Easter Sunday with Catholics in Shanghai

Easter Sunday with Catholics in Shanghai

Grotto

"Tinsel, Frankincense, and Fir"

"Tinsel, Frankincense, and Fir"

Dana Gioia

Why We Can’t Rush Others Into Forgiveness

Why We Can’t Rush Others Into Forgiveness

David Liambee Gbe

What to Know About Making Friends as an Adult

What to Know About Making Friends as an Adult

Ellen B. Koneck

3 Ways You Can Repair a Sibling Relationship

3 Ways You Can Repair a Sibling Relationship

Claire Collins

12 Ways to Spend a Volunteer Year

12 Ways to Spend a Volunteer Year

Marye Colleen Larme

What My Cancer Taught Me About Hope

What My Cancer Taught Me About Hope

Mary Beth May

4 Ways to Respond When Your Goals Feel Out of Reach

4 Ways to Respond When Your Goals Feel Out of Reach

Robert Christian

"Desperately seeking some guidance"

"Desperately seeking some guidance"

Stephanie Konrady

newsletter

We’d love to be pals.

Sign up for our newsletter, and we’ll meet you in your inbox each week.